Olympic spring has sprung for Pistorius, maybe

An international court ruling has given South African 400-meter runner Oscar Pistorius approval to compete in the Summer Olympics.
The double amputee told reporters in Italy, “I think this day is going to go down in history for the equality of disabled people.”
The issue is that some view Pistorius’ “disability” as being qualitatively similar to that of a NASCAR Chevy being accidentally equipped with too little internal engine friction and too much horsepower. Pistorius, wearing two giant springlike devices in place of his lower legs and feet (picture below the “fold”), basically runs like a velociraptor once might have, inasmuch as Stephen Spielberg can be trusted as a paleozoologist. Many have argued that if anything, Pistorius runs faster than he would have were he using the legs he was born with, and is in effect riding a one-cylinder Harley in the Tour de France.


oly_g_pistorius_600.jpg
Pistorius’ best time, 46.56 seconds, is well short of the 45.55 needed to qualify for Beijing in the open 400. He could compete as a member of the 4 x 400 squad without an individual qualifying time, but the South African team hasn’t qualified in that event either.
The Paralympics were conceived to give people who were presumably compromised by severe injuries or cruel tosses of the genetic dice to compete for global championships. Does the fact that no one foresaw the day when technology might transform partial mechanical compensation into an outright mechanical advantage imply that athletes such as Pistorius should be, as some would assert, penalized?
That’s debatable, but one thing is certain — Pistorius is bent on having it both ways:

Pistorius said he will be running in both able-bodied and Paralympic events before Beijing … [he] also expects to compete in Beijing at the Sept. 6-17 Paralympic Games.

Sorry, dude. Pick one or the other. In 1997, U.S. mile superstar Paul McMullen cut off a few toes mowing his lawn, but he didn’t try to enter the Paralympics. Instead he returned to run a 3:54 mile the next year and a 3:33 1500 meters (equivalent to about a 3:50 mile and one of the top 10 U.S. times ever) in 2001.
One observer at Letsrun.com, probably the Web’s pre-eminent track and field discussion forum, wryly referred to him as “handicapable.” A poll on the front page of the same site asking whether Pistorius should be allowed to run in the Olympics currently has the O-man down by a 3-to-1 margin.
My suspicion is that Pistorius’ bid for the traditional Olympics will be more likely to accrue favor in track fans’ minds if he is willing to set aside his Para plans now that his appeal to run in the regular Olympics has been upheld. But he won’t, because he hasn’t run fast enough to qualify for Beijing and is thus hedging.
Go vote in the poll, or not. But my overriding thought is this: I’d rather see American pedestrians rambling the streets in Pistoresque devices than tooling along on those friggin’ Segways.

Advertisement
  1. #1 by Jeb, FCD on May 17, 2008 - 8:18 pm

    I couldn’t believe this when I saw it on the MSM. As a fat guy who completes triathlons, I know my calf muscles end up producing loads of lactic acid that drain my efficiency (I know this is a minor point). This guy is a troll. As you said, pick one or the other. Those composite legs retain their elasticity and have several other advantages that normal people don’t enjoy.
    I’m sorry he’s an amputee, but damn.

  2. #2 by Jeb, FCD on May 17, 2008 - 8:26 pm

    Isn’t handicapable from South Park?

  3. #3 by Norm on May 17, 2008 - 9:03 pm

    Interesting, so if the IOC allows him to compete, how long will it be before able bodied sprinters have both legs amputated below the knees in order to fit these devices? I’m only half joking.

  4. #4 by Kevin Beck on May 17, 2008 - 9:05 pm

  5. #5 by Kevin Beck on May 17, 2008 - 9:05 pm

  6. #6 by Bill from Dover on May 18, 2008 - 1:49 am

    Wow! Looks like there’s still room on them for a couple of Acme rockets.
    Beep, Beep.

  7. #7 by Epicanis on May 18, 2008 - 2:30 pm

    Personally, I think someone should set up an “unlimited” athletic competition where “anything goes”, so long as all of the activity is still powered by the athletes’ muscles (and so long as all athletic participants are giving informed consent for whatever they’re doing to maximize performance). I think it’d not only be fun to watch, but it’d provide a venue for studying and developing prosthetic devices and medical treatments.
    Personally, I stopped caring about the Olympics®™ entertainment industry long ago, when it became obvious to me how much it had become just another corporate sports entertainment franchise.

  8. #8 by Kevin Beck on May 18, 2008 - 2:54 pm

    Epicanis,
    Sure, there’s a valid argument to be made there. Forget drug testing and the like and let the athletes dope to the tops of their eyeballs and do whatever else tey can to make them faster, stronger or springier. Look at corporate America, where in order to function at 100% and put in 65- to 80-hour weeks, professionals from Wall Street drones to law clerks load up on caffeine (a gateway drug), martinis (at first after work, then during), uppers, Prozac, therapy, Pilates, extramarital affairs, soul-selling, backstabbing and whatever the hell else is necessary to make them financially secure. Anyone really think that most U.S. workers always have their long-term health in mind when they’re out plying their thing? Riiiiiiiiiight.
    Treating athletes differently is the epitome of a double standard — we expect them to be the quickest and the most skilled and the most powerful and then we cap those quantities by telling them to Say No to Drugs? Fuck that shit.
    Still, for now at least, rules are rules, and liars and cheats are lying cheats.
    I hope the advent of genetic tinkering allows us to breed a new class of quadriped-human that can run a 2:30 mile. Imagine! These “people” would have thigh muscles three feel long and have to live in stables. They’d look a little like Pinocchio and friends did when they were out on Pleasure Island and just starting to transmogrify into ass-people in order to pay the karmic piper. Wheeeeeeee!

  9. #9 by hopper3011 on May 18, 2008 - 4:57 pm

    Kevin;
    I posted this earlier, but it seems to have become lost in the tubes. I don’t know if you noticed but Guenther Weidlinger won the Great Manchester (the one in England) Run today. He ran 28:10, beating Sergiy Lebid and Luke Kibet.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.